I talked to Amy Lee of Evanescence about challenging the world’s worst fanfiction

Evanescence Performs At Royal Competition Hall London

Picture by Joseph Okpako / WireImage

Filed below:

The singer of My Immortal (the song) has now read My Immortal (the fanfic)

While you mention the title “My Immortal,” you could well presumably also just indicate one among two issues. The predominant is the 2003 hit song from rock band Evanescence. The 2d is a Harry Potter fanfic so transcendentally, mysteriously rotten that it’s transfixed the online for years.

The fanfic My Immortal is set a time-traveling mall-goth teenage vampire wizard (named “Ebony Dusky’ness Dementia Raven Plot”) who’s hooked in to Evanescence and a unfold of goth-inflected rock bands. She’s supposed to test love Amy Lee, Evanescence’s lead vocalist, pianist, and songwriter. And to at the 2d, no one is stir who wrote the legend or whether or not they enjoy been serious.

Abet in the precise world, Lee and the leisure of Evanescence enjoy spent months below protect-at-home orders all over the coronavirus pandemic. They’ve aged that time to film two tune videos in collaboration with director P.R. Brown, each and each shot by band contributors and their households. The most fresh is a surreal video for “The Sport Is Over,” a song from their upcoming album The Bitter Fact. In Lee’s phrases, it’s shot as a “psychological thriller,” stuffed with imagery in step with a particular dread or inner demon from each and each member.

These videos — filmed in dwelling rooms, vehicles, and other non-public spaces — give fans a brand fresh extra or less examine into the band contributors’ lives. But I used to be exclusive a pair of different extra or less fan relationship: did the creators of “My Immortal” know about My Immortal? I spoke to Lee, and the reply is definite; in actuality, it’s section of a prolonged-running family joke. She’d never of route read it, nonetheless, except final week.

The following interview has been condensed and lightly edited for clarity.

You’ve made two videos below quarantine, and they’ve taken very different approaches. What used to be the technique in the support of every and each of them?

We of route had to accurate reflect extra or less posthaste. We enjoy been working on one other video medications that would enjoy been full-manufacturing, this entire take care of a large crew and issues we are able to also not enjoy resulting from of the pandemic — together with the indisputable truth that we couldn’t even physically ranking together resulting from we live accurate thru the world.

We known that “Wasted on You” had a bunch of lyrical inform that felt love each and each of a unexpected where we enjoy been. So we went for that. I of route wished it to be precise on a level love of us hadn’t seen us earlier than: in our own homes, in our precise lives, not dressed up, not in makeup, accurate the precise, uncooked us.

For the 2d one, it’s love “K, how bring together we spend what we’ve realized and amp it up even extra to assign it examine love an exact video bigger than accurate us being ourselves?” We have all been very taking into account the lockdown, so we have been fully alone for the most section all over this time — and that’s frigid in many ways as a creator. But you of route enjoy to live together with your self the entire time.

Just a few of us enjoy long passed thru some sophisticated issues in the previous few years. [Bassist Tim McCord] and I each and each skilled losses in our instantaneous family. There’s accurate been pretty a pair of laborious. So that you realize if you happen to’re in the demolish pressured to discontinue being distracted by the entire issues that encourage us delighted, there’s silence — and that stuff comes out. So each and each of us had a non-public extra or less gut-spilling confession with [P.R. Brown] about what we’re fighting.

We enjoy been accurate sharing deeply in a technique that we don’t on the entire meander the entire plot with in phrases of not lower than our visuals. When I pour my lyrics into my tune, it’s persistently of route uncooked. But on this, it’s love, we’re not going to encourage support on the video aspect and accurate assign it comely — we’re going to transfer for it and let or not it’s gruesome and part the darkish substances of ourselves.

I reflect of pretty a pair of your tune as being launch and inclined, and you engage with fans on-line. What does filming a video at home love this talk that your regular social media presence and tune don’t?

I’m hoping it accurate reveals an increasing number of of that willingness to be inclined resulting from as laborious because it’s miles, it persistently leaves me feeling extra overjoyed than accurate putting on a reasonably face.

Social media’s this kind of weird world for me. I of route uncover it irresistible — I’m grateful for the postulate that we are able to enjoy an instantaneous relationship with our fans. But it for stir’s extra or less a double-edged sword. It’s such an launch platform for each person to criticize every thing about you. And if you happen to transfer there, you’re going to glance that. I reflect that’s honest for each person. It doesn’t topic if you’re a celeb or not. It’s accurate a station where of us don’t enjoy to display veil their face to advise issues, and there’s pretty a pair of gruesome available.

Heavy Montreal 2019

Picture by Impress Horton / Getty Images

What’s your relationship particularly with fanworks? Create of us ship you issues that enjoy been impressed by you?

Oh my god, it’s so good. We’ve obtained so noteworthy art. I’ve obtained this immense collection of stuff that I’ve been putting on to accurate from the starting set. There are so noteworthy of talented of us available that pour their efforts into making a section of visible art that is either of something in the Evanescence world or accurate something else that got right here out of them whereas they enjoy been paying attention to our tune.

Then there are other issues that or not it’s valuable to encourage resulting from they’re so hilariously humorous. Folks will assign a crazy poem that makes solely no sense but I’m a personality within it, which is awesome. It’s love, I do know this person’s love 12 years dilapidated and solely real, but this is so humorous. I enjoy somewhat studio, and I dedicated somewhat bit of time all over our unexpected free time to duvet it wall-to-wall in the john with the entire fan stuff.

Which brings me to my subsequent quiz: had you ever heard of My Immortal?

I reflect for pretty a whereas I used to be accurate unaware of it. After which my cynical, Reddit-loving younger sister who’s also an English teacher, someplace all over the vacation each and each year when the family’s all together, it’ll advance up for some reason. And he or she’s love, “Wait — you mute haven’t read My Immortal?” And I’m love, “No, what bring together you indicate?” She’s love, “It’s most sensible to have to. K, encourage on. Let me read you an excerpt.” After which she’ll pull up her cellphone and read some awesome paragraph from the craziest, funniest divulge ever that just just isn’t sensible.

It’s one among her accepted issues that she thinks is the most hilarious divulge on the earth, and I mute accurate kept not reading it. It’s been extra or less this ongoing joke with us. After which I obtained a call a pair of days ago that you wished to chat about it, so I used to be love, “Oh, crap. I enjoy to read somewhat bit of it.”

I read I reflect not pretty 1/2 of it, nonetheless it did enjoy me in tears. I used to be laughing of route, of route laborious at one point, accurate resulting from of the nonsense. After which I started asking myself, is that this precise? I will’t pretty picture. I’m solely undecided. Is it real? I of route feel uncover it irresistible started presumably as real, but they obtained in on it and started taking part in it up for the haters. I will’t picture! What bring together you observed?

It would could maybe just mute be so justify, but there are a bunch of cases that of route assign it seem love this person is conscious of noteworthy, noteworthy bigger than the personality they’re putting on.

I realized a misspelling that used to be love, as an different of triumphantly, it used to be “triumelephantly.” And I used to be love, advance on, you don’t reflect “elephant” is inside “triumphant.” There’s no plot.

At one point, the dear personality’s title is spelled two different ways within three phrases of 1 one more.

I solely saw that, too! I’m torn resulting from I want it to be real, extra or less… but I don’t know.

There are issues about it that aren’t frigid to chat about. Enjoy it’s not humorous to chat about slitting your wrists. So it takes me a 2d to ranking previous that joke, which is so routine.

Yeah, if you meander support to dilapidated net tradition, pretty a pair of it’s miles of route gruesome. And it’s weird attempting to separate that stuff out.

Is it greater now?

I don’t know resulting from now I’m too dilapidated to know what’s occurring. But children bring together seem nicer. They on the entire seem nicer.

I would actually like to take into accout of we’ve grown up somewhat bit as a society from that. Presumably each person having somewhat bit extra of a microphone has taught us some issues that we are able to also just mute be attentive to which are launch air of our perception and our non-public experiences. There are other of us which are seeing that otherwise. I reflect it can well be frigid if that’s honest.

I used to be a baby spherical when My Immortal got right here out, and it feels uncover it irresistible describes a extremely recognizable “goths versus preps” rivalry. Did you of route feel that?

I reflect this divulge is poking fun at that world — I indicate it can well could maybe just mute be, advance on — and that section of it of route resonates with me in an exact plot. But I didn’t encourage in mind myself goth! Section of what’s weird and humorous is love okay, this is describing hating the preps, and you’re the frigid one, you’re the underground, you realize precise life and the gravity of loss of life, and I ranking it. But if you’re so uncomfortable and every thing’s so laborious and you’re so precise and they’re so faux, why bring together you set so noteworthy effort into your examine?

That used to be what persistently became me off about the note “goth” when that started being assigned to me in our early days. If I used to be 15 years dilapidated and you’d requested me what I used to be, I’m grunge. I decide all my dresses at garage sales, I don’t bring together crap to my examine, I ranking ready two seconds earlier than college, and the entire preps are those who set all their take care of their appears to be like and what social gathering they’re going to transfer to.

But yeah, that section used to be humorous to me. That section existed.

I of route love the postulate of you luminous about this divulge for years with out having read it.

I extra or less resolve on to thank you resulting from I did ranking a of route accurate snicker out of it final evening. It’s not love, after I enjoy free time, I’m motivated to transfer read some horribly rotten divulge. But it for stir’s of route rather fascinating.

And also you’ve gotta treasure the entire characters breaking into song to allege My Chemical Romance songs. It’s rather gigantic.